Mergers for purpose (not profit!) can be transformative – for the organisations involved and for the beneficiaries you serve.
However, they are rarely linear or simple. Good intentions and aligned purpose are no guarantees of success. In this article we explore 6 risks that come up from first conversation through to completion, and how to mitigate or avoid them altogether.
Key Takeaways
- Waiting too long: "We've been talking about this for years." By the time action is taken, the opportunity — or the potential partner — may have gone.
- Overestimating your value: Your brand, people and history may be valuable. But so are your partner's. The real question is: "Why would they want to do this with us?"
- Focusing on what you can gain: If you're trying to protect the past or secure more clients, assets or influence, you're starting in the wrong place. Start with: "What could we achieve together that we can't achieve alone?"
- Too many non-negotiables: "Our brand must stay." "We can't lose any staff." "We need board seats." Protecting the past can easily prevent you from building the future.
- Under-resourcing the process: Mergers need time, leadership capacity, expertise and money. They can't simply be added to an already overloaded CEO's workload.
- Communication failure: When there's a communication vacuum, fear and assumption fill it. Staff worry, donors disengage and members can lose confidence.
1 — Not acting in time
"We have been talking about this for years"
I continue to be amazed how many Boards say this when we work through what a merger involves. There have been multiple conversations behind closed doors, often based on hypotheticals or abstracts, without documenting anything or actually talking to potential partners because of false assumptions or a fear of getting it wrong.
Then when finally some organisations get into gear (eg engage with an advisor, speak to a possible partner) it's too late and the opportunity has been missed.
For those who see a partnership as way to scale impact, the world has changed around them – others have moved first, another organisation has shown the initiative, the environment changed, potential partners may have moved on.
For those under financial stress, assets have worn down, best staff have left due to cultural decline or fears about job security, remaining leaders are in protection or panic mode; the organisation is on life support — not exactly an attractive partner!
Mitigation
- Put collaboration on the next board agenda with structure and resolutions.
- Move from talk to action. Delays just reduce options and appeal to possible partners.
2 — Overestimating your 'value'
It's a common mistake that Leaders, when finally exploring collaborations, expect others to be queuing up for their IP, their clients, their brilliant staff and systems, their valuable brand or to leverage their proud history.
But there is a reason no one has been knocking down their door. Potential partners have their own IP, their own staff and systems, their own brand and history.
If the organisation has been in decline, the value of donors and staff is reduced, and if they have worn down their asset base due to delays, there's less or no financial 'sweetener' to any arrangement.
So, what would the partner actually gain through a merger? What's in it for them? Its probably less than you might think.
Mitigation
- The most value you bring to a possible partnership is when things are going well. There's money in the bank, a buoyant culture, talented staff, energised funders. That's the best time to talk with organisations with whom you share a purpose. (See article — the time to repair the roof is when the sun is shining)
- Maybe there is value you can bring to a potential partner, but be realistic, and consider things from their perspective.
- Be humble. Be empathetic. Be open. Be curious.
3 — Seeking to gain rather than contribute to a higher purpose
If a prospective partner does see value in working with you, the approach and mentality you take into the relationship can be decisive in determining whether or not a positive outcome is achieved.
If you approach a partnership simply looking to protect your past, believing you're better or more 'right' than them, or hoping to 'get' something (clients, size, footprint, assets), you are setting yourselves up to fail.
This creates false expectations and a negative, transactional, defensive approach. Not a great basis for a purpose-led relationship.
Mitigation
- Rather than what can you 'get', start with a North Star, a mission-led, shared higher purpose (help more people, do more good, provide better support, extend the social impact).
- Build on commonalities not differences.
- Maintain a focus on The Possible — the shared purpose that makes them a potential partner in the first place.
4 — Non-negotiables scupper the deal
Bringing a long list of non-negotiables into a partnership discussion can kill the chances of a successful outcome before it has chance to emerge. They can get in the way of the shared, higher purpose and often reflect a desire to protect the past, rather than explore future possibilities (see #3). But it happens so often.
- Our brand must survive
- We mustn't lose any staff
- We need seats at the board table
- Service X must continue
These are all understandable — and often entirely justifiable — but only in the service of the higher purpose. There are always ways to structure things to meet these non-negotiables, but the more that are layered, the less room in which to build a successful partnership.
Larger partners entering merger discussions from a position of strength might assume their work will not have to significantly compromise.
But in a merger of equals, or even more so for the smaller organisation looking to 'merge into' a larger partner, non-negotiables reduce the chance of a successful outcome and takes away from appeal as a partner.
Mitigation
- Be realistic about your value and position coming into a partnership (see #2 above).
- Consider each potential non-negotiable against your North Star objectives, and if they don't serve the higher purpose, reconsider them.
5 — Fail to resource with talent, time and treasure
So if you have mitigated the risks above, and you do get to the start line with one or more partners, there are new pitfalls to dodge.
One of the greatest threats to a successful process is leadership risk.
Expecting an already challenged and busy CEO to invest more time and energy (and it will take both!) in the merger process — attending and supporting committees, getting and sharing information, communicating with staff etc — increases the risk of CEO quitting or leaders burning out (which is already a heightened risk at a time when executives might worry about their roles through this process).
Losing key people can derail the merger process. Supporting with consultants and contractors can provide extra resource and continuity through this complex and sensitive process.
Moving too slowly is also a huge risk. The slower you move, the more any underlying issues can grow, higher the risk of a challenge with your partner, your own risk of leadership issues (see above) and broader unease and disengagement amongst stakeholders.
Lastly, expecting to go through the process without incurring any costs is unrealistic. Direct costs will include advisors (consultants, lawyers, IR/HR, branding etc) and systems implementation. If redundancies are involved, they need to be factored in, and if you want your team to deliver a merger on top of BAU in order to minimise additional costs, the chance of leadership issues, or a protracted process become compounded, so a budget could also include backfilling roles and contract support.
Mitigation
- Experienced guides (consultants) can speed things up and avoid losing time with missteps or losing focus to other distractions.
- Quick, strong decision-making processes are vital (think empowered committees, regular board sessions, strong and brave board leadership).
- Aim to move as quick as possible to grasp the opportunity when it presents, and only slow enough to give due consideration to important questions and bring stakeholders along the journey.
- A dedicated budget for expert support, backfilling and contingencies gives the project a chance to succeed.
6 — Communication failure
Communication on a project as sensitive as a merger is complex, and the greatest risk here is that fear and assumption fill a communication vacuum.
If you keep them in the dark, clients, donors, members and staff will hear about the process but won't feel part of it.
Staff may gossip, disengage, then leave – fearing what the merge means for their role. Donors may walk away if they feel devalued through the process. Clients may worry what this means for them. And a common risk for Member based organisations is that disengaged Members vote against the process at the necessary EGM.
Communication needs to be staged; kept to a small group (Board/CEO?) in the early stages, but as you progress, new stakeholders groups are engaged for example staff usually need to be engaged before going 'public' to donors etc – but map this out and if in doubt, err on the side of communicating early, honestly and openly rather than sharing too little, too late.
Mitigation
- Draw up clear messages on what's happening and why.
- Create a plan for who should hear what and when.
- Communicate regularly and clearly.
- And when (not if!) things aren't yet known, or they change, explain why and what will happen next.
If you're at the beginning of a potential journey — starting to talk about what a merger might achieve for you — book in a free planning call to map out and avoid these pitfalls.


